This is the most biased Scribe SEO review you’ll ever read. Why?
Well, for one, I designed and developed scribeseo.com. Secondly, I had a hand in the development of the Scribe platform.
That said, bias isn’t all that bad. In fact, in this case it just allows me to give you a magnified review of Scribe.
If you’re not familiar with Scribe yet, here’s a bit about it:
Scribe is an SEO software service for WordPress that analyzes the content of web pages, blog posts, online press releases, you name it… at the click of a button.
The Scribe API then reports back to the WordPress interface and tells web writers, bloggers, affiliate marketers, and small business owners how to tweak their content to get more search engine traffic, all while maintaining quality reader-focused copy.
Let’s assume you’ve installed and configured the plugin (which is pretty easy) and you’ve written a post. Now, you just hit the “Analyze” button and Scribe gives you its report…
SEO Score Card
The first screen you’re presented with is the score card — an overview of scoring factors and recommendations. It gives you a quick glance at things you can do to improve your copy.
The Good
Beyond a simple interface that highlights the changes you need to make, it scores a host of factors that make the score card quality:
- Character and word count of the title
- Title keyword usage and placement
- Character and word count of the description
- Description keyword usage and placement
- Character and word count of the body
- Body keyword usage and placement
- Keyword density
- Hyperlink count and prominence
- Reading ease
The Bad
Every post/page is unique and following the recommendations blindly could hurt you. Achieving a score of 100% shouldn’t be your goal. Keep in mind that the analysis is only scanning the content you’ve just written and not the rest of the content that will appear around the post (header, sidebar, footer, etc.). As long as you remember that the score card is a guideline you’ll be ok.
Keyword Analysis
You’re likely writing content with the hopes that people will find it through a search engine (duh!) so you need to be aware of what keywords people are going to use to get to your page. Its pretty tough to pull these out of the air. You never know if a word you might search for is what other people would use. So, we have keyword analysis…
The Good
There’s some tools out there that let you paste in your content and specify the desired keyword. Well, like I already said — you don’t really know what people are searching for. Scribe takes the guess work out of it finds the keywords you are using. You can see which words will likely get you ranked and then you can make a judgment call about whether you want to target that term. Fortunately, that call is easy to make with all of the data provided.
- The keyword’s rank within your content
- Prominence
- Frequency
- Density
- Annual Search Volume
Plus, Scribe gives you suggestions for making keywords more of a primary keyword or less.
The Bad
Despite what any analysis tells you, there aren’t any hard and fast numbers to determine what the golden number of keywords should be. So, the suggestions Scribe gives are based upon industry theories, but like most SEO advice, they need to be taken with a grain of salt.
Tags
Categories and tags are used in WordPress for organization which helps users just as much (or more) as it does search engines. Sometimes its hard to remember to add tags. Even more difficult is to come up with tags.
The Good
Scribe gives you semantically relevant terms that you can use as tags. These are terms that the plugin as determined to be good search keywords and are relevant to the content of your page or post.
The Bad
Scribe should give you an option to add tags to your post. Maybe a check box and an “Add to post” button? Its not all that bad, but would be a time saver.
Conclusion
I’ve left out a handful of other features (SERP example, SEO best practices, integration with WordPress themes and plugins, etc.). Although, I’ve covered the meat and potatoes of what make Scribe SEO what it is.
Scribe for WordPress is an excellent plugin that can be used by anyone and is especially helpful for those that already know what they’re doing but just need to save time.
Just remember that SEO can’t be completely automated and it requires some common sense. With that in hand, I give Scribe two thumbs up. But don’t take my word for it.
Affiliate links were used in this post.
Related posts:




[...] Scribe SEO Review [...]
Hey, Patrick. (Great name!)
Just wanted to say that the Scribe website is very sharp. Nice job.
And I’m enjoying using Scribe myself. It’s good to see someone emphasize that going for a 100% on the scorecard is not necessarily the goal. Nor, I would add, is it a guarantee that you’ll get good search engine rankings. Thanks for the tips.
Pat
Its always good to have a realistic perspective. People are too often let down by products that they allow themselves to get to emotional about. Scribe is another tool in the box, not a magic wand!
Thanks for the compliments; glad you like the site!
If you’re at all interested, I wrote up my own Scribe SEO review. Unfortunately, I failed to mention how good-looking the Scribe website it. So I’ll just say that here. :-)
Sir I too enjoy the plugin and had some suggestions via my article
http://www.darrenmonroe.com/wordpress/online-business-ideas-scribe-seo/
Darren,
You’ve got some great ideas there! Scribe has a long way to go so I wouldn’t be surprised to see many of those ideas implemented in due time.
Social comments and analytics for this post…
This post was mentioned on Twitter by developdaly: Scribe SEO Review http://goo.gl/fb/mVAZ...
[...] If you are interested in getting another opinion on what Scribe SEO is all about, here is what Lis has to say about Scribe SEO and here is what Patrick Daly has to say in his Scribe SEO Review. [...]